mystery mail: the secrets of rosewater house
Mystery Mail is a six-month, serialized mystery experience told through deeply personal documents that feel real. Each month, FBI Special Agent Rowan Price writes directly to you, sharing new clues and emotional revelations as you help her unravel the death of bestselling romance novelist Evelyn Sinclair. Every mailing is like opening a new episode of a mystery drama — only you’re inside the story.
Real Characters. Real Emotions. Real Stakes. You won’t find generic suspects or cookie-cutter clues here. Every character has depth, history, contradictions, and emotional truth. Special Agent Rowan Price writes with a voice so authentic you’ll forget she isn’t real. Each of her letters pulls you deeper into the mystery.
Each mailing is designed like an episode of a high-end, character-driven series. Layered. Emotional. Addictive.
There are no puzzles to “unlock.” No ciphers. No gimmicks. Your job is to understand the people, their motives, and their secrets — and draw your own conclusions. In the end, you’re not just solving a mystery. You’re stepping into a living, breathing world that reveals itself piece by piece. A world where every clue matters. A world where every episode casts a longer shadow than it first appears. A world that needs someone like you.
Your 6-Month Experience Includes:
- ✉️ 6 Episodic Mailings. A new chapter of the story is delivered to your mailbox every month for six months.
- 📜 Character-Driven Letters. Each mailing is built around a primary four-page letter written to you from FBI Special Agent Rowan Price, plus other letters, notes, or writings from characters or suspects in the story.
- 🗝️ 60+ Physical Items. Discover tangible items in every envelope that are vital parts of the mystery. Hold authentic-looking FBI documents, examine photographs, discover intriguing evidence, and more.
- ❤️ An Unforgettable Mystery. Experience a fully realized story and mystery for you to solve with a forbidden romance, a compelling secret, and a satisfying conclusion that unfolds at a suspenseful pace.
Verified Reviews
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "The emotional depth in this story is unbelievable. Lots of twists and turns and it'll keep you guessing right until the very end. This isn’t just about solving a crime. It’s about understanding a woman’s life, her marriage, her friendships, her hopes, her regrets. It’s beautifully written and honestly heartbreaking at times." - Mark T., Greenville, SC
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I forgot I was reading fiction. I opened the first one and immediately felt like Agent Rowan Price was talking directly to me. The writing is phenomenal. The characters feel so real." - Virginia P., Los Angeles, CA
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I’m not a gamer. I don’t like puzzles. But this? This is a story. A mystery told in letters, photos, and documents. You feel like a character in Evelyn’s world. I couldn’t recommend this more." - Sara G., Brookville, OH
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "This series always delivers top notch materials that feel real. Great mystery. Good quality and high value." - Debra H., Arrington, TX
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I was picked to be a test reader for this while it was still being developed. I read a lot of thrillers and crime fiction, and this holds its own against the best of them. The characters are nuanced, the clues are subtle, and the suspense builds month after month. Brilliantly done." - Kelly L., Hopedale, IL
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "This was a fun activity for my husband and I to do together. It feels like Special Agent Price is a real person writing to you. The letters are so vivid and personal that I found myself wanting to write back. I don’t think I’ve ever connected with a fictional character in this way before. The combination of mystery and emotional storytelling is perfection." - Katherine R., Holtsville, NY
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Incredibly well-written and emotionally powerful. I was not expecting such depth. The author definitely understands human behavior — the jealousy, the hope, the desperation. I finished each episode feeling like I needed to talk to someone about what happened." - Allison A., Lansing, MI
Your New Favorite Obsession
Evelyn Sinclair, a bestselling romance novelist, is found dead inside her private writing studio. At first, it seems obvious who might be responsible.
But nothing about Evelyn’s world is simple. Her life was glamorous. Her secrets were devastating. And someone she trusted is lying. Through Agent Rowan Price’s letters, you’ll uncover the truth. Every letter feels personal. Every detail feels alive. If you want a story you can fall into, this is it.
It’s a six-month relationship with Rowan Price, with Evelyn Sinclair, with the people who loved and hurt her. By the end, you’ll feel like you lost, and found, someone real.
THE CREATOR
I'm Christopher Forrest, a bestselling author and former trial attorney. I write and design every new mystery and story using my background as a lawyer and novelist to create experiences that feel authentic, intelligent, and utterly addictive. I hope you enjoy my mysteries as much as I enjoyed creating them.
WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Okay, so here’s what happened. I opened the first mailing, told myself I’d just skim through it, and then realized almost an hour had passed. I was in it. Completely gone. My husband walked by and asked why I looked emotional and I said, “Because Adrian is DEFINITELY lying but I don’t know WHY yet,” and he just slowly backed out of the room. In all seriousness: this is the most fun I’ve had with a fictional world in a long time. It’s juicy. It’s emotional. And it’s so beautifully written that you forget it's fiction. 12/10, will analyze strangers’ facial expressions for potential alibis now." - Olivia N., West Sunbury, PA
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "The documents are so authentic and so well-written, it’s easy to forget these people aren’t real. I kept rereading certain pages because the emotions hit so hard. This is storytelling done right." - Dana H.,Westford, MA
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "There’s nothing generic about this. The emotional tension, the gorgeous writing, the realism. It all comes together to create something genuinely unique. If you love mysteries with depth, don’t hesitate." - Lauren L., Greenwich, NY
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Rowan Price is my new favorite fictional character. Her "voice" is so good. Vulnerable, sharp, and compelling. The way she talks to you makes you feel like you’re actually helping her investigate. I want more of her story in the next arc." - Scott H., Granite City, IL
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I wasn’t prepared for how deeply this would pull me in. I thought I was signing up for a fun little mystery, but what I found was something so much richer that made me feel things I didn’t expect. Price’s letters are written like she knows you, trusts you, confides in you. There were moments I had to set the letter down because I felt like I was reading something I wasn’t supposed to see." - Tabitha F., Long Beach, CA
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I’m someone who has tried multiple mystery boxes and interactive experiences, and I can confidently say this: Mystery Mail is on a completely different level. The quality of the documents is exceptional, but what sets this apart is the emotional depth. The creator clearly understands that the best mysteries aren’t about puzzles, they’re about people. Evelyn’s relationships are complex and painfully believable." - Skip D., Dublin, CA
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "This experience meant more to me than I expected. I recently lost someone close to me, and seeing Evelyn's life, fears, and dreams laid out so intimately hit me right in the heart. There is so much humanity in this story. And the ending was devastating in the best way." - Bethany T., Scott Air Force Base, IL
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "I’m 33 and I binge everything. Books, dramas, podcasts, you name it. Mystery Mail gave me something I didn’t expect, a slow, delicious drip of story that made me WAIT. And I loved the anticipation. Rowan’s letters are addictive. The characters feel like they belong in an HBO series. And the evidence pieces? Instagram-level aesthetic but with emotional punch. I’ve already convinced two friends to order the next one they make so we can all scream about it together." - Holli A., Red Lion, PA
Escape into a world of mystery.
Most mystery experiences or games ask you to solve puzzles. This one asks you to understand people. From the very first letter, Rowan Price treats you like her partner. Not a player. Not an observer. Someone who needs to feel the emotional truth of each character to make sense of the mystery.
It’s immersive. It’s emotional. It’s unlike anything you’ve ever opened in the mail.
If you love stories that make you feel as much as think, you’re going to fall in love with this experience.
FAQs
We offer a 100% Satisfaction 30-Day Guarantee. If you are dissatisfied with Mystery Mail, please let us know within 30 days of receipt of your first episode and request a refund via email or contact form. Refunds are not automatic with cancellations and must be requested via email. The relevant refund amount will be returned to the original payment method within 7 - 10 business days.
Refunds after 30 days
After the Full Refund Guarantee expires (30 days), refunds are not available for monthly or prepaid subscriptions, and you are committed to payment for the full 6-month term. The remainder of the subscription will be mailed to the address provided.
Visit our website, choose Mystery Mail, and add it to your cart.
Shipping
• Enter your recipient’s shipping address so their Mystery Mail episodes will be sent directly to them.
• For multiple recipients at different addresses, complete the order for the first recipient, then place a new order for each additional recipient.
Billing
Enter your own billing information. All billing details will be sent to the email you provide.
Complete Your Order
After each order is completed, check your email for the order confirmation.
Each episode of Mystery Mail ships during the last week of each month. We will send a USPS tracking notification upon mailing.
The episodes will be sent approximately every 30 days for the duration of the experience.
Mystery Mail episodes are written primarily for adults and mature teens. We would rate Mystery Mail as PG-13 (that’s not official, of course, it’s just our opinion). Mystery Mail episodes do not contain any profanity, visual depictions of violence, or explicit sexual language, but they do contain adult themes. While we feel that Mystery Mail episodes are appropriate for those who are 13 and up, we recognize that many people have different opinions about content that is appropriate for different ages, and we would encourage you to screen any content before presenting it to someone younger than 18 years of age to ensure that it meets with your standards of what is appropriate.
Internet access is not required to enjoy Mystery Mail.
